How To Train Your Dragon
I’ve wanted to talk about How to Train Your Dragon for a while now, and last week’s review of Merrie Haskell’s Handbook for Dragon Slayers and the resulting comments about disability in fiction made me finally sit my butt down to do it.
I love this movie. I love the story, I love the message and themes, I love the humor … there’s very little it gets wrong, in my opinion. I would have appreciated more female characters, but even there, as I understand it, the movie improves on the source material.
The story is pretty straightforward. Hiccup is basically a nerd among Vikings. He works as an apprentice to the village blacksmith, but he lacks the physical strength and battle prowess of his fellow Vikings, and is more interested in gadgets and inventions that don’t always work. Oh, and his village is constantly fighting off dragons.
I’m rather fond of Jay Baruchel, the actor who voices Hiccup. He’s got a very distinctive voice, and his sardonic and often self-deprecating tone works for me.
During one dragon raid, Hiccup manages to shoot down a Night Fury, the deadliest breed of dragons. The Night Fury’s tail is crippled, leaving it unable to fly. Hiccup tracks where the dragon fell, planning to finish it off and prove himself, but he can’t do it. Instead, he studies and slowly befriends the dragon, which he names Toothless (because Night Furies have retractable teeth).
Toothless is awesome. The expressiveness and humor the animators capture in every scene is amazing. This dragon, who never says a word, is a better actor and character than most humans. I love the details, whether it’s watching him scorch a circle and turn around before settling down to sleep, or the obvious love and loyalty he develops for Hiccup. (Love and loyalty which are returned in full.)
Some of what follows is predictable, of course. Hiccup uses his secret dragon knowledge to impress the other Vikings and improve his standing, only to fall when the truth comes out. There’s a low-key romantic thing between Hiccup and Astrid. The dragons turn out to be more than simple livestock thieves, and there’s a big old battle at the end. While the twists aren’t entirely original, they’re well done and engaging.
But one of the things I most respect about this movie is how it handles disability.
SPOILERS AHEAD
The blacksmith, Gobber, has lost an arm and a leg, and the movie does the “Look at all the cool weapons and toys I can plug into my wrist” bit with his character. But with Toothless and later Hiccup, it’s presented seriously, without either minimizing the pain and the work or going overboard with Very Important Messages About Overcoming Adversity.
You see Toothless’ frustration and fear when he’s unable to fly, and an admittedly condensed process of Hiccup building and fitting the prosthetic tail, then the two of them learning to use it to fly together.
But what really works for me comes after the final battle. Hiccup is injured and loses his leg. You see him awaken back home in his own bed, start to sit up, and realize what’s happened to him. He has a wood-and-iron leg now, built by Gobber.
Skinny though he might be, Hiccup is still a Viking, so you’re not going to get a lot of outward grief. But you see the sadness and loss in those few seconds before he stands. He takes one step and starts to fall, only to have Toothless dart in to catch him. The two of them together make their way toward the door, giving the viewer a silhouetted shot of Hiccup’s new foot and Toothless’ prosthetic tail. The whole sequence is less than a minute long, but it’s one of my favorite scenes of the whole movie.
Short version: It’s a very well-written and visually entertaining movie. Y’all should watch it.
Shecky
February 11, 2013 @ 10:35 am
One thing that especially amused my wife and me was how INCREDIBLY much Toothless’ expressions, mannerisms and actions mirrored those of our cat Betty (short for “Bête Noire”). We kept elbowing each other throughout both of our in-theater viewings of the movie (“God, how often have we woken up to THAT?” was one of our many whispers), and we did the same when we got the video.
My wife is addicted to the extra stuff you get when you buy the video. I was on my computer in the back room when she was watching the HTTYD extras, and she summoned me with a wordless squee: Toothless was almost entirely modeled on the animator’s cat. Extra bonus? Our cat Betty is solid black. 🙂
Wielli
February 11, 2013 @ 10:49 am
I rewatched the movie only yesterday and feel exactly the same way as you do about it. The heart-warming relationship between Toothless and Hiccup, the true-to-life depiction of disability, the strength of character displayed by all of the characters at one point or another. HTTYD is by far my favourite animated movie of the last decade.
As for the female characters, I didn’t think there was a lack of female representation, because the girls / women made their scenes really count. Astrid is no shrinking violet, she knows her worth and stands up for herself, and gives Hiccup strength when he needs it. Ruffnut has nothing on her brother. And there are women on board when the Vikings set out to battle the dragons on their island, just as strong as the men.
ithiliana
February 11, 2013 @ 11:03 am
Chiming up to say I too loved this film–though I completely read Toothless as a female dragon (in part, perhaps, because, like Shecky, I have a dark tortie cat–Luthien–and was so reminded of her via Toothless–and aha, proof in the extra features).
Jim C. Hines
February 11, 2013 @ 11:05 am
I had to double-check as I was working on this post, but I was pretty sure the film refers to Toothless as male.
Then again, who’s to say Hiccup can accurately tell the sex of a dragon nobody’s ever seen before? 🙂
Shecky
February 11, 2013 @ 11:06 am
Gotta wonder if teeth are the only retractable things on the Night Fury. *rimshot*
Tera Fulbright
February 11, 2013 @ 11:57 am
Love this post! My husband and I loved the movie and are enjoying the cartoon series just as much. Something about the story captures so much more than just overcoming adversity. It touches on friendship and family and trust and…Yeah well. It’s good.
DaveD
February 11, 2013 @ 11:59 am
There’s a blogger in Toronto (Dave Hingsburger) who blogged about this movie a couple years ago. Dave Hingsburger is himself physically disabled and lectures to the mentally disabled being self-advocates as well as caregivers. One of the best blogs I’ve ever read, for no other reason that it’s humanness (he’s not dry, he isn’t emotionless and he might ever curse occasionally).
KatG
February 11, 2013 @ 4:11 pm
“Thank you for nothing, you useless reptile.” is one of my favorite movie lines ever. My daughter only occasionally watches animated kids movies these days, being in high school, but this is one she’s seen twenty-seven times. There’s a sequel coming out next year. The wonderful part of the movie is the attention to detail. Also, it was perhaps the best use of Gerard Butler ever. The scene about the mother’s helmet causes me to die each time. They did make Toothless deliberately cat-like. And the scene where he’s trying to get the rudder on Toothless’ tail — if you’ve ever had to give a cat a pill or cut out a mat of fur, etc., it’s very funny.
Sally
February 11, 2013 @ 4:27 pm
Toothless is DEFINITELY a kitty (she said, with a dark tortie next to her).
I haven’t seen the extras, so it’s kind of Shecky to confirm this for the rest of us!
Astrid is a better Viking than the boys, but unafraid to be friends with the gentle nerd kid. I think she’s a wonderful character.
Am also certain that Hiccup will invent the finest artificial leg on earth, all jointed like Toothless’ rudder.
Sally
February 11, 2013 @ 4:35 pm
My tortie also has a clubfoot and came very close to being put down as a kitten because of it. She’s about as slow as Toothless.
Lark
February 11, 2013 @ 10:01 pm
What a wonderful review, Jim! I found myself nodding agreement with everything you said. And I love this movie!
Tansy Rayner Roberts
February 12, 2013 @ 12:33 am
I love the movie! The book is excellent but very gender problematic – no women in sight at ALL except for occasional reference to Hiccup’s mother.
The movie is way, way better. I was also delighted to see that the Wii game based on it allows players to choose between Hiccup and Astrid as avatars, which adds to the gender-friendly nature of it.
Toothless in the movie is a wonderful character, beautifully conveyed.
If anyone does want to compare to the books (which are very good kids action adventure pieces despite the lack of girl adventurers) I highly recommend the audio book versions, read by David Tennant in his broad Scottish accent.
AMPillsworth
February 14, 2013 @ 10:36 am
The sequence in which Hiccup first gets Toothless’s trust, from the fish delivery through the touch, is one of my favorite in animation. Brilliant!
Jane
February 14, 2013 @ 5:59 pm
You will be pleased to find out there is a series! As well as sequel movies, there is a show called Dragons: Riders of Berk.
Vera Nazarian
February 15, 2013 @ 5:50 pm
Totally agree with you, Jim. I LOVE this movie. It is nearly flawless in every way emotionally and story-wise.
I think they modeled Toothless on cat and dog behavior, because he is as REAL as any beloved pet. Just love it, thanks for reminding me how much! 🙂