Political Hyperbole
I’ve seen several people linking to this article about Rick Santorum, an article titled “Santorum: ‘I’ll Die’ to Stop Same Sex Marriages.” The links have sometimes included comments about the messed-up priorities of a man who would sooner die than permit a loving, same-sex couple the same kind of rights he enjoys as a straight man.
There’s a problem. What Santorum actually said was:
“The battle we’re engaged in right now is same sex marriage, ultimately that is the very foundation of our country, the family, what the family structure is going to look like. I’ll die on that hill.”
You see that last bit? “I’ll die on that hill.” That’s what we call a figure of speech.
I wrote on Friday that I was going to write the crap out of a chapter. I was not, in fact, using my keyboard to extract literal feces from my document. I was using a figure of speech to more colorfully describe my efforts to improve the story.
Look, I find a lot of Santorum’s views and statements to be despicable. But my feelings are based on what he’s said and done, not on twisting his words into something he didn’t say.
I don’t care where you fall on the political spectrum. When you distort (or outright lie about) what someone said in order to try to score points, you lose credibility.
This has been Jim’s cranky political post of the day. Thank you for listening, and enjoy the rest of your weekend.
Bryan Thomas Schmidt
October 22, 2011 @ 5:06 pm
Thanks, Jim. Important words these days. We have enough division and nastiness already without people getting the facts straight. We all would do well to be careful to make sure we have our facts before getting worked up, when hyperbole is so common.
sara g
October 22, 2011 @ 9:44 pm
In other words, there are plenty of legitimate reasons to be appalled by certain politicians without having to make stuff up.
Jim C. Hines
October 22, 2011 @ 10:19 pm
This is true…
zollmniac
October 22, 2011 @ 11:35 pm
Politics is nothing but the distortion of what the other side says and contains very little facts or basis in reality.
I’d like to see a government that actually focused in the problems we have as a nation instead of just slingingg dirt at each other. I don’t care how something is taken out of context… Just fix the fucking country already!
pooks
October 23, 2011 @ 9:21 pm
Thank you! I get so tired of receiving emails that are at best, hyperbole, often a cut-and-paste and highly edited material designed to mislead, and at worst outright lies, only to be told by the person who sent it to me, “It doesn’t matter if it’s exactly true, it’s funny,” or some other excuse as to why it’s okay to keep sending it around.
Words matter. Truth matters. Facts matter.
And if you can’t make the point without twisting or making things up, then maybe it’s not a true point, anyway.
Anita K.
October 24, 2011 @ 12:45 pm
Yeah…. Santorum has said enough terrible, terrible things in reality that it wouldn’t have shocked me had he said this, but misrepresenting his words doesn’t do anyone any good, unless maybe you’re a teacher looking for examples of logical fallacies (Straw Man anyone?). :p You’re entirely right, it DOES make the people who say this or spread it around lose credibility.